HomeMy WebLinkAboutMontana Dept of TransportationMontana Deportment of Transportation Jim Lynch, Director
July 20, 2005
2701 Prospect Avenue
PO Box 201 O01
Helena MT 59620-1001
Mayor Kenneth E. Olson, Jr. and/or Laurel City Council
City of Laurel
P.O. Box 10
Laurel, MT 59044
Brian Schweitzer, Governor
Subject:
Information ReqUest
ProJect Name: Big Ditch -9 km W of Billings
ProJect No.: BR 532-1(10)12
CN: 4884
Dear Mayor Kenneth E. Olson, Jr. Olson and Laurel City Council Members:
The Montana Department of Transportation is evaluating potential environmental impacts that may be
associated with the above project. With this letter we are requesting your assistance to help us
conduct a thorough analysis and we are inviting The City of Laurel to provide comments or helpful
information on the proposed project.
The proposed project is located at Reference Post 13.78 on Secondary Route 532, locally known as
King Avenue West, approximately 5.6 miles (9 kilometers) west of Billings where it crosses Big Ditch.
The Structure is in Yellowstone County, Section 7, Township 1 South, Range 25 East.
The existing structure is a single-span timber bridge, 7.92 meters long and 7.41 meters wide. The
bridge was built in 1959 and is listed as functionally obsolete and eligible for rehabilitation. It is
expected the existing bridge will be replaced with a culvert. The existing horizontal alignment will be
used as is. The vertical alignment will be followed as closely as possible while allowing for the
required hydraulic opening and the size of the culvert required. The limits of the project will be based
on the minimum required approach length to tie the new culvert into the existing roadway. The total
length of the project is expected to be less than 650 feet (200 meters).
The new roadway will be designed for a width of 28 feet (8.4 meters) consisting of two 12-foot (3.6
meter) lanes and two 2-foot (0.6 meter) shoulders. The culvert length will be determined by clear
zone requirements so that no guardrail will be required.
Big Ditch diverts water from the Yellowstone River. This water runs through Big Ditch for irrigation
purposes until it terminates in the town of Billings in Section 35, Township 1 North, Range 25 East.
Big Ditch does not return flow to a Water of the United States. Big Ditch is operational between April
15th and November 1st.
Big Ditch is not a judsdlctional Water of the United States as determined by the U. S. Army Corps of
Engineers in their letter to MDT dated January 10, 2005. Big Ditch is not under the Jurisdiction of the
Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Parks. Therefore, neither a 404 Clean Water Act Permit
nor a 124 Stream Protection Act Permit will be required for this project. Please review the enclosed
Preliminary Field Review Report for additional specific details about the proposed project.
Environmental Services Bureau Engineering Division
Phone: [406} 444-7228 An Equal Opportunity Employer TrY: 1800] 335-7592
Fox: (406) 444-7245 Web Page; www, mdt, mt, gov
IJuly 20, 2005 Project Number: BR 532-1(10)12
Laurel City Council/Mayor Project Name: Big Ditch - 9kin W of Billings
Page 2 of 2 Control Number: 4884
If you have comments or potentially helpful information, please forward those comments to MDT at
your soonest convenience. To ensure that your comments are captured with the correct project, in all
correspondence please refer to the Project Number and Control Number listed above. If MDT does
not receive a wdtten response within thirty (30) calendar days, we will assume that The City of Laurel
has no comments or concerns about this proposed project.
If you have any questions, please phone Heidy Bruner at 406.444.7203 or email her at
hbruner@mt.gov. She will be pleased to assist you. Thank you for your assistance.
Sincerely,
Tom Hansen, P.E.
Engineering Section Supervisor
Environmental Services Bureau
TLH:hsb: S:~PROJECTS\BILLINGS\4884ENTWNCSP01.DOC
encl: Preliminary Field Review Report
cc: Jean A. Riley, P.E. - Chief, Environmental Services Bureau
File
Preliminary Field Review Report
BR 832-'1 (10)12
Big Ditch - 9 km W of Billings
Control No, 4884
Project Work Type 223
Introduction
A preliminary field review for the project was held on March 20, 2002. The following personnel
participated in this review:
Gary Neville DESS Billings
Don Vanice R/VV Billings
Damian Krings Road Area Engineer Helena
Kevin McCray Bddge Area Engineer Helena
Bob Nelsen Maintenance Billings
Dave Leitheiser Hydraulics Unit Helena
Tim Tone Bridge Bureau Helena
Jim Tompkins Surfacing Design Helena
Shannon Schultz Planning Helena
Dick Lewis Design Supervisor Helena
Proposed Scope of Work
The proposed project was nominated to replace this functionally obsolete timber structure crossing Big
Ditch approximately 9 km west of Billings. It is expected the existing bddge will be rep[aced with a
culvert. The existing horizontal alignment will be used. The vertical alignment will be followed as
closely as possible while meeting current design standards.
Proiect Location and Limits
The proposed project is located on Secondary Route 532, locally known as King Ave. W,
approximately 9 kilometers west of Billings where it crosses Big Ditch. (See the map on next page.)
The structure is in Yellowstone County, Section 7, TlS, R25E, at reference post 13.78. Reference
posting begins at the northern city limits of Laurel and increases to the north to where S401 begins.
Reference posting then increases to the east and terminates at the junction with U1031. Project
stationing will increase to the east. The limits of the project will be based on the minimum required
approach length to tie the new culvert crossing to the existing roadway.
Hesber
Location Map
Physical Characteristics
The existing bddge is a single-span timber structure, 7.92 meters long and 7.41 meters wide, skewed
30 degrees. The bridge was built in 1959, and the current sufficiency rating is 58.6. The existing
structure is listed as functionally obsolete and eligible for rehabilitation.
The terrain at the crossing is level and the adjacent land use is primarily irrigated fields, although
several homes exist near the crossing. Approaches exist at three corners of the bridge. The structure
was originally built under project S 192(2)42, The existing surfacing is bituminous treated surfacing of
unknown depth, and the approach roadway width is approximately 7.3 meters. The existing inslopes
appear to be 3:1.
The existing bridge is in.' :: condition. Some cracking and rutting is F ent in the asphalt covered
timber deck. Timber stn,.~ars exhibit superficial splits, checks and cra,.~s. Light scour is present at
Abutment No. 2. Details of the existing bridge are listed below:
Year Built 1959
Inventory Number SOO 532 011+08781
Length, m 7.92
Width (curb to curb), m 7.41
Number of Spans 1
Span Length, m 7.62
Bridge Rail Type Steep W-beam
Superstructure Type Timber stringers
Abutment Type Timber Piles
Sufficiency Rating 58.6
Structure Status Functionally Obsolete/Eligible for Rehabilitation
Traffic Data
2002ADT = 660 Present
2005ADT = 700 Letting Date
2025ADT = 1060 Design (Future)
DHV = 130
Corn Trucks = 6.9%
80 kN ESALs = 36
Growth Rate = 2.1%
Accident History
A computer accident analysis was conducted for this project. There were two recorded crashes
involving this structure dudng the ten-year analysis period, from January 1, 1992 through December
31, 2001, according to the Transportation Information System. In 1995, a vehicle westbound at night
on dry pavement crossed to the left side of the road and struck the bridge guardrail to avoid an
oncoming eastbound vehicle crossing the bridge in the wrong lane. In 1997, a vehicle westbound in
daylight on dry pavement went out of control, struck the right side bridge guardrail and went into the
irrigation ditch.
Major Design Features
Functional Classification - This roadway is functionally classified as a Major Collector.
Design Speed-The design speed for the project is 100 kilometers per hour based on the design
criteria for Rural Collector Roads with paved surfaces.
Horizontal and VerticalAliqnments - The existirig horizontal alignment is on a long tangent, and will be
used as is. The length of new roadway will be determined based on the required grade raise for the
new structure. The total length of the project is expected to be less than 200 meters. The vertical
alignment will be established based on the required hydraulic opening and the size of culvert required.
Typical Sections - The new roadway will be designed for a width of 8.4 meters consisting of two, 3.6
meter lanes and two, 0.6 meter shoulders. This width is based on the route segment plan for Rural
Collectors with current AADT less than 1000 and DHV between 100 and 199. The culvert length will
be determined by clear zone requirements so no guardrail will be required. The proposed surfacing
will be 75 millimeters of Grade C plant mix on 300 mm of gravel, and crowned 2%. The finished
surface will taper to the existing roadway width at the project limits. The surfacing inslopes will be 4:1;
fill slopes will vary from 4:1 to 1.5:1 based on fill height; and v-ditches will be used.
Grading - Grading for this project will be accomplished with Embankment-In-Place.
Safety Enhancements - Pavement markings will be included with the project. Existing mailboxes will
be replaced and mailbox turnouts provided.
Hydraulics - The structv ,! =s not within a delineated floodplain; theref a permit w not be required
Channel modifications a~,~. :not anticipated. Debris, drift and ice do n(~t -d~pear to be a problem. - '
Construction activities in and around flowing water are not anticipated. Current design and
construction specifications will minimize any water quality impacts. For additional information, see the
Location Hydraulic Study Report.
Right of Way
This project will require new right of way.
Utilities/Railroad
A conduit is attached to the north side of the bddge. There are overhead power and phone lines
located south of the bridge and a gas line spanning the channel. There are no known existing water
and/or sanitary sewer lines using this crossing. The project will have no railroad involvement.
Design Exceptions
The use of nonstandard design elements is not anticipated for this project at this time.
Traffic Control
The road will be closed and traffic will use an alternate route during construction. The detour length
from one bridge end to the other is approximately 6 kilometers.
Steam Access
This canal crossing is private property and closed to public access,
Environmental Considerations
A Section 404 permit will be required. No 4(f) or 6(f) lands were identified at the Field Review. A
programmatic Section 4(f) evaluation is required due to the canal crossing. Environmental Services
wilt prepare the appropriate environmental studies and documents.
Public Involvement
A news release to the appropriate newspapers explaining the project will be produced.
Salvage
State Maintenance forces want salvageable stringers from the existing structure. The Contractor will
dispose of the remaining materials according to Standard Specifications.
Survey Requirements
A conventional survey will be completed for this project. The hydraulic survey requirements are
identified in the Location Hydraulic Study Report for the project. A survey request is attached to this
report,
Proiect Management
Billings District Road Design will manage the preconstruction phase of this project.
Cost Estimate
The current cost estimate for the project is $190,000, which includes 15% for mobilization, '10% for
contingencies, 15"/o for construction engineering and a 3% annual inflation rate for three years. PE
costs are not included. The culvert cost is based on a unit cost of $4000 per meter. Construction cost
from Road Design for the road approaches is estimated at $50,000.
Cost breakdown is as follows:
New Box Culvert '
New Approach Roadways
Remove Existing Bridge
Subtotal
+15% Mobilization
+10% Contingencies
+15% Construction Engr.
+ 3 yrs. Inflation
60,000
50,000
10,000
$120,000
$140,000
$150,000
$170,OO0
$190,000
Ready Date
Engineering Management will set a firm ready date when activity durations are received from the
appropriate design units.
BIG
/
DITCH 9 KM W i~F"~ILLINGS
BR 532 1(10)
6f~UGI'U~F. I 0
60053201
~ll& 01 fC, H
36
POPULATION
~ Canyon
~'~ YELLOWSTONE
~OUNTY