HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Council Minutes 12.03.1996Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
December 3! 1996
A regular meeting of the City Council
held in the Council Chambers and called to
p.m., on December 3, 1996.
COUNCIL MEMBERS PRESENT:
Gay Easton
Bud Johnson
Miles Walton
of the City of Laurel, Montana, was
order by Mayor Chuck Rodgers at 7:00
Dirk Kroll
Donna Kilpatrick
William Staudinger
COUNCIL MEMBERS ABSENT: Norman Orr
Ron Marshall
INVOCATION: Invocation was given by Alderwoman Kilpatrick.
MINUTES:
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of November 19, 1996, as presentedl seconded by Alderman Easton. Motion
carried 6--0.
Prior to the council meeting, Mayor Rodgers introduced Travis Pitts, the new
police officer.
CORRESPONDENCE:
Received a letter from the Montana Department of Commerce informing us that
Laurel was selected for funding through the 1996 HOME program.
Received a copy of a letter to Monty Cranston from Cal Cumin regarding the
Laurel Zoning Ordinance.
Received a newsletter from the Montana League of Cities and Towns.
Received a letter of resignation from Police Chief, Mike Atkinson, effective
July 1, 1997.
Mayor Rodgers received a letter from Ruby Hanson that did not get in tonights
correspondence. It is being taken under advisement and copies will be handed out
later.
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick to accept Mike Atkinson's resignation as
Police Chief, effective July 1, 1997, seconded by Alderman Johnson. Motion
carried 6--0.
CLAIMS:
Claims for the month of November were reviewed by the Budget/Finance Committee
and recommended that they be paid.
Motion by Alderwoman KilDatrick to approve the claims in the amount of
$380,929.12 for the month of November, seconded by Alderman Johnson. Motion
carried 6--0.
DICK BLACK - STREET/SIDEWALK ON WEST 13TH STREET:
Dick spoke to the council on behalf of himself, Gwen Hoffman, and George
Bangert. He stated that he built his home on West 13th Street in 1994. At the
time he bought his building permit, the city required him to install a curb and
sidewalk. He explained the sidewalk and curb started to settle the following
spring. He filed an incident report in June of 1995 and spoke to Jim Flisrand.
Dick said he was told that Jim would take this issue to the Utilities Committee
and instructed him to send the paper work to Alexis, the city's insurance
company. The sewer line is directly under the curb and sidewalk and was never
compacted. Dick said he has spent over a thousand dollars in repairs already. He
feels the city has overstepped their boundary because 13th Street is in the
county, yet all three of them were required to put in a curb and sidewalk.
He is asking the city to do something about the issue before he takes further
action. He explained the insurance company turned him down and feels Jim did not
take the matter to the Utilities Committee or council. He said 13th Street is in
the county and that the city does not want anything to do with them, therefore,
they are getting the run around. Dick stated they are paying city taxes and are
not getting anything in return from the city.
Mayor Rodgets appointed a committee to address the issue. Jim Flisrand, Joe
Leckie, Bud Johnson, Gay Easton, and Donna Kilpatrick were appointed.
Dick showed the council the building permit he purchased May 16, 1994. He said
Page 2
Council
Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
Meeting of December 3, 1996
inspection on the sidewalk and curb before he could pour it.
the elevations, the location, and inspected it before it was
REMOVE ORDINANCE NO. 096-5 FROM THE TABLE:
Public hearing was held on October 1, 1996.
The city gave him
poured.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to remove Ordinance No. 096-5 from the table,
seconded by Alderman Walton. Motion carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-5 (second reading)
AMENDING TITLE 17 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE, ZONING
Motion by Alderman Johnson that Ordinance No. 096-5 (second reading! be
passed and adopted including the City of Laurel zoning map revised September 17,
1996, seconded by Alderwoman Kilpatrick.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES". Motion
carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-7 (second reading)
AMENDING SECTION 15.12.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM BUILDING CODE 1994 EDITION
Public Hearing: No comments.
Motion by Alderman Kroll to close the public hearing, seconded by
Alderwoman Kilpatrick. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderman Easton that Ordinance No. 096-7 (second reading) be
passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES". Motion
carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-8 (second reading)
AMENDING SECTION 15.16.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE CABO ONE AND TWO FAMILY DWELLING CODE 1995
EDITION, INCLUDING AMENDMENTS
Public Hearing: No comments.
Motion by Alderman Easton to close the public hearing, seconded by Alderman
Kroll. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick that Ordinance No. 096-8 (second reading}
be passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES". Motion
carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-9 (second reading)
ADDING SECTION 15.24.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE MODEL ENERGY CODE 1993 EDITION
Public Hearing: No comments.
Motion by Alderman Easton to close the public hearing, seconded by Alderman
Walton. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderman Walton that Ordinance No. 096-9 (second reading) be
passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES". Motion
carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-10 (second reading)
AMENDING SECTION 15.28.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE ABATEMENT OF DANGEROUS BUILDING CODE, 1994
EDITION
Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
Page 3
Council Meeting of December 3, 1996
Motion by Alderman Easton to close the public hearing,
Kroll. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderman Easton that Ordinance No. 096-10
passed and adopted, seconded by Alderwoman Kilpatrick.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted,
ORDINANCE NO. 096-11 (second reading)
AMENDING SECTION 15.36.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM SIGN CODE 1994 EDITION
Public Hearing: No comments.
Motion by Alderman Easton to close the public hearing,
Kroll. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderwoman KilDatrick that Ordinance No. 096-11
be passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted,
carried 6--0.
ORDINANCE NO. 096-12 (second reading)
seconded by Alderman
(second reading) be
"YES. Motion carried
seconded by Alderman
(second reading)
"YES". Motion
AMENDING SECTION 15.40.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
TO ADOPT THE UNIFORM FIRE CODE 1994 EDITION
close the public hearing, seconded
Public Hearing: No comments.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to
Alderman Walton. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderman Johnson that Ordinance No. 096-12 (second reading)
passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Staudinger.
vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES".
ORDINANCE NO. 096-13 (second reading)
A roll call
carried 6--0.
by
Motion
that Resolution No. R96-52 be passed
Motion carried 6--0.
AMENDING SECTION 1.12.010 OF THE LAUREL MUNICIPAL CODE,
Public Hearing: No Comments.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to close the public hearing,
Alderman Easton. Motion carried 6--0.
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick that Ordinance No. 096-13 (second
be passed and adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
A roll call vote was taken and all aldermen present voted, "YES".
carried 6--0.
BURLINGTON NORTHERN GRANT - LOG CABIN FIREMEN'S PARK:
RESOLUTION NO. R96-52
A RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE SUBMISSION OF A BURLINGTON
NORTHERN SANTA FE FOUNDATION GRANT APPLICATION FOR
ADDITION TO THE LOG CABIN IN FIREMEN'S PARK
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick
adopted, seconded by Alderman Easton.
seconded by
reading)
Motion
and
RESOLUTION NO. R96-53
A RESOLUTION APPROVING AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY
OF LAUREL AND MORRISON MAIERLE, INC., RELATING TO A
WATER RATE STUDY
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick that Resolution No. R96-53 be passed
adopted, seconded by Alderman Johnson.
and
Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
Page 4
Council Meeting of December 3, 1996
Alderman Kroll asked why the city would need the water rate study?
Jim addressed the question by explaining that the city will need to increase the
water rates to compensate the cost of the water project which will be
approximately four million dollars. Therefore, it is necessary for the city to
have a consultant to develop an accurate rate increase rather than the city
determining what the increase should be. The city needs to assess the business
industry and residences to determine a suitable increase for all facets.
Morrison Maierle is the engineer on the water plant project and is completely
aware of all aspects of the program. They do rate structures and it would be
reasonable for them to do a rate structure for the city.
Jim explained that in the past the city has simply multiplied the old rate with
a factor for a new increase. Due to the fact that the PSC is no longer a
governing body reviewing rate increases, the next step would be for a person to
go to district court if they do not agree with the rate increase. Therefore, the
city needs to be very diligent in their efforts to make an accurate assessment
of the rates.
The city had considered both Double Tree, Inc. and Morrison Maierle, Inc. to do
a rate study. Double Tree did not respond to our request for a proposall
therefore, we would recommend we follow through with Morrison Maierle. The water
project is in the final stage for approval on the plan specifications. The rate
structure is the next step to continue with the project. The resolution will
authorize Morrison Maierle to do the study. They will submit their final results
to the Public Utilities Committee for review and then present them to the
council for approval.
Alderman Walton commented that it is very important for the city to have a study
done on the water rate increase, that will be defendable in court, rather than
have the city's staff come up with a figure to meet with what is needed. He
feels Morrison Maierle has an excellent rate study program. Morrison Maierle
would complete a program for the city.
Dave Mosser, Morrison Maierle, mentioned that the study will represent more of
the actual costs of the system and meet the basic needs. The program has the
capability of being simplistic or being more complex in detail, depending on the
level at which the city wishes to continue or break down the costs of the
projects. A certain amount of revenue needs to be generated to meet the cityls
obligation. The program will allow this to be set up into both fixed base costs
and variable operational costs. The program will allow the city to continue to
modify and upgrade the city's system over the years.
A vote was taken on the motion to pass and adopt Resolution No. R96-53.
carried 6--0.
Motion
UPDATE ON THE WATER PLANT PROJECT:
Jim presented a chart showing cost figures for the water improvements and
explaining various options and increases to the project.
The following proposed improvements are:
1. Clearwell/Chemical Building
2. Backwash Basin
3. Plant Auto. & Upgrade
4. Storage Tank Rehabilitate
5. Floc./Uncovered Sediment Basin
Resurface Floors & Walls
Repair Common Walls & Baffles
6. 18" Water Mains
S. 1st Ave. - S. 4th to Railroad
N. 1st Ave. - Railroad Ave. to N.
7. Plant Conference Room
8. Emergency Generator
(may be worked into project)
Street
1st (may be worked into project
(may be worked into project
(may be worked into project
Depending on the alternatives, the construction cost (debt service) would create
a rate increase of approximately $13.00 to $14.60, to the existing water bill
per month.
With the approval of the council tonight,
study and then present it to the
recommendation.
Morrison Maierle will do a water rate
Public Utilities Committee for a
Dave Mosser commented on the alternative improvements to resurface floors and
walls in the sediment basin, the addition of a plant conference room tha~ can h~
Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
Page 5
Council Meeting of December 3, 1996
Street and 1st Avenue North. These improvements were put into the bid as
alternatives. It will be to the council's discretion at bid opening whether they
want to add the alternative improvements to the water plant project. Dave said
they will continue to look at these alternatives in the rate study.
Dave explained that due to different issues the project has not progressed as
rapidly as they expected. They are hoping for the project to be bid around
February 1, 1997. Painting of the tanks cannot be done until about April. The
tanks are an intricate part of the project. They are hoping for construction to
start by April 1, 1997.
COMHITTEE REPORTS:
--Budget/Finance Committee minutes of November 19, 1996 were presented and
reviewed.
Motion by Alderwoman KilDatrick to enter the Budget/Finance
minutes of November 19, 1996, into the record, seconded by Alderman
Motion carried 6--0.
Committee
Johnson.
Motion by Alderwoman KilDatrick to approve the assignment of Paul Strom and
Associates, CPA's, as the city's auditorl seconded by Alderman Walton. Motion
carried 6--0.
--City Council Committee of the Whole minutes of November 19, 1996 were
presented.
Motion by Alderwoman Kilpatrick to enter the City Council Committee of the
Whole minutes of November 19, 1996, into the record, seconded by Alderman
Johnson. Motion carried 6--0.
--Police/Personnel Committee special meeting minutes of November 20, 1996 were
presented and reviewed.
Motion by Alderman Kroll to enter
meeting minutes of November 20, 1996,
Johnson. Motion carried 6--0.
the Police/Personnel Committee
into the record, seconded by
special
Alderman
--Public Utilities Committee minutes of November 18, 1996 were presented and
reviewed.
Motion by Alderman Walton to enter the Public Utilities Committee minutes
of November ]8, 1996, into the record, seconded by Alderman Easton. Motion
carried 6--0.
--public Utilities Committee minutes of November 25, 1996 were presented and
reviewed.
Motion by Alderman Walton to enter
of November 25, 1996, into the record,
carried 6--0.
the Public Utilities Committee
seconded by Alderman Johnson.
minutes
Motion
--Street & Alley/Garbage Committee minutes of November 21, 1996 were presented
and reviewed.
Motion by Alderman Easton to enter the Street and Alley/Garbage Committee
minutes of November 21, 1996, into the record, seconded by Alderman Staudinger.
Alderman Easton stated that the committee has met with Mr. McMilin, school
superintendent, regarding the issues of painting curbs, placement of signs,
restricted parking, loading, and sanding.
A vote was taken on the motion. Motion carried 6--0.
Jim Flisrand commented on items in the Street and Alley/Garbage Committee
minutes. The first item he referred to was Mr. Murray's property that is a
triangular parcel, 165 square feet area, on West 12th Street, south of the
walking bridge. The issue has been discussed in the past. The property is too
small to serve any purpose and it needed to be identified legally on a plat. Mr.
Murray prepared a quit claim deed and wishes to give the property to the city.
Jim would like to have a resolution at the next council meeting to authorize the
Mayor to sign an agreement. He asked the council for their acceptance of the
quit claim deed so the process could be started.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to start the process for a quit claim deed on
Mr. Murray's property, the triangular parcel of land, 155 square feet area, on
West 12th Street, south of the walkin~ brid~e. ~enonded bv A]H~Pwnm~n
Minutes of the City Council of Laurel
Page 6
Council Meeting of December 3, 1996
Alderwoman Kilpatrick asked Jim if there will be a problem for weed control and
maintenance on the triangular parcel?
Jim said the city mows one width of the ground along 12th Street now, even
though it is in the county. The property is small, 155 square feet, which the
city may end up mowing anyway. The cost to maintain the property is very
minimal.
A vote was taken on the motion. Motion carried
Jim also wanted some direction from the council to start the process to expand
the snow removal district.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to start the process to expand the snow removal
district, seconded by Alderman Walton. Motion carried 6--0.
Jim Flisrand commented that a meeting was held with Mr. McMilin and the issues
of sanding, painting curbs, restricted parking, loading and unloading, container
site fees, and recycling were discussed. He sent a letter to Mr. McMilin to
identify all the items and feels they had a good meeting and are ready to move
ahead. The curbs will be painted and proper signs will be installed, The school
will need the council's approval of the areas to be marked, either by painting
curbs or placement of signs for restricted parking or loading and unloading, The
committee will look at the cost along with the entire project and give a
recommendation to the council.
He discussed sanding the streets around the schools. The budget does not include
the school district's property. There is also a question of liability. If the
streets are sanded one day, missed the next day and an accident happens, is the
city liable? This would be a judgement call. These are two reasons that have
prevented the city from sanding in the past.
Alderman Easton noted that a meeting will be scheduled with Mr.
Programs Administrator for MMIA, regarding right-of-ways. The
item that could be discussed.
Bob Worthington,
sanding is one
COMMENTS FROM THE AUDIENCE:
Alderwoman Kilpatrick requested permission to leave the state from December 14,
1996 to January 1, 1997.
Motion by Alderman Johnson to grant permission for Donna to leave the state
from December 14, 1996 to January 1, 1997, seconded by Alderman Staudinger.
Motion carried 6--0.
Cal Cumin reminded everyone of the meeting on December 4, 1996 on the downtown
planning at the Locomotive, 6:00 p.m.
Jim announced a Street and Alley meeting on December 12, 1996 at 5:30 p.m.
open bids on a garbage truck and a pickup.
to
There being no further business to come before the council at this time, the
meeting was adjourned at 8:17 p.m.
Donald L. Hackmann, City Clerk
Approved by the Mayor and passed by the City Council of the City of Laurel,
Montana, this 17th day of December, 1996.
Donald L. Hackmann, City Clerk
~les Rodgets, ayor